Proof document

Independent Test Summary: Malodour And Airborne Microbe Reduction

A careful EcoBreeze proof summary explaining reported independent malodour and airborne microbe reduction evidence, test boundaries, procurement use and claims wording requirements.

EcoBreeze · Updated

Summary for buyers

Executive Summary

This is the plain-English version of the EcoBreeze independent test evidence.

It is designed for procurement teams, facilities managers, FM providers, cleaning contractors and healthcare or care-sector buyers who need to understand the proof before they specify EcoBreeze Standard or EcoBreeze Pure.

What This Summary Is For

Use this document when a buyer asks:

  • what independent evidence supports EcoBreeze
  • whether EcoBreeze has been tested beyond internal product claims
  • what the reported 89 percent and 80 percent figures mean
  • whether the evidence applies to EcoBreeze Standard, Pure or Smart
  • what can be included in a tender response
  • what evidence needs to be approved before public or tender use
  • how to avoid health, compliance or field-performance overclaims

This is a proof summary.

It is not the full evidence file.

It should sit alongside:

  • the original St. Croix Sensory report
  • the original airborne microbe report, once supplied
  • the original Odournet report, if used
  • current EcoBreeze product datasheets
  • approved product configuration wording
  • approved claims wording
  • installation and service guidance
  • any current certificates or technical declarations

Read The Original Malodour Reports

Original reportWhat was tested
Odournet carbon-filter efficacy report (PDF)Stale-urine malodour in 3 m³ chambers; carbon filter fitted versus removed, with both fans running continuously at medium setting and fragrance disengaged
St. Croix Sensory malodour-reduction report (PDF)Strong synthetic faecal malodour in 2.16 m³ chambers; wall-mounted units at medium fan speed, comparing carbon-only and carbon-plus-Tropical Heaven fragrance configurations

These are sensory malodour studies, not microbiology reports. Their results apply to the configurations and conditions described; they do not establish health outcomes, universal site performance or the performance of the freestanding Residential configuration. Confirm the relationship between the tested device and the current model being specified before using a quantified result.

Evidence Status At A Glance

Evidence pointSource statusBuyer-safe interpretationBuyer-safe use
89 percent malodour reduction within 30 minutesReported by CSSA and supported by public St. Croix Sensory PDF for a tested Washroom Wizard configurationIndicates strong controlled-chamber malodour reduction under defined test conditionsUse with clear test-condition wording and product-equivalence context
80 percent airborne microbe reduction within 30 minutesReported by CSSA Innovation Showcase materialIndicates a potentially important microbiology evidence pointTreat as supporting evidence until the original microbiology report and method details are available
Activated carbon roleSupported by EcoBreeze product pages, science content and general EPA/ASHRAE contextSupports filtration-first positioning and odour-capture explanationUse to explain why EcoBreeze is not simply fragrance masking
Fragrance-free use in PureSupported by EcoBreeze Pure positioningSupports no-added-fragrance route where fragrance masking is unsuitableUse for Pure positioning, avoiding medical or allergy-safe claims
Healthcare, care and education relevanceSupported by buyer need and sector contextEvidence can support buyer due diligenceKeep the wording operational rather than clinical, infection-prevention, allergy or compliance-led
Real-world site performanceNot proven by a chamber report aloneField performance depends on room, source, cleaning, ventilation, placement and service routineAvoid universal guarantees and site-specific performance promises

What The Malodour Test Appears To Show

The public St. Croix Sensory PDF describes a fecal malodour test for a Washroom Wizard device.

The report explains that:

  • a strong simulated fecal malodour was introduced into closed test chambers
  • odour was assessed over time
  • trained assessors evaluated the chamber air
  • a control chamber was compared with device chambers
  • the test included a carbon plus fragrance configuration and a carbon-only configuration
  • the reported carbon plus fragrance result showed 89 percent odour reduction after 30 minutes
  • the report also describes further reduction over the longer test period

This is useful because it supports a clear buyer point:

EcoBreeze has evidence that its filtration-led approach has been independently assessed in controlled malodour testing, rather than relying only on fragrance perception or internal claims.

But the result has a boundary.

The report does not mean every washroom will achieve the same reduction after the same time. Commercial washrooms vary by:

  • room volume
  • airflow
  • extraction
  • humidity
  • odour source
  • cleaning routine
  • drain condition
  • sanitary waste management
  • cubicle layout
  • product placement
  • footfall
  • service condition
  • filter age
  • whether fragrance is used

That is why the strongest wording is not "EcoBreeze removes 89 percent of washroom odour in every site."

The stronger and safer wording is:

Independent chamber testing reported 89 percent reduction of a simulated fecal malodour after 30 minutes for the tested carbon plus fragrance configuration. The full report, tested configuration and approved wording should be supplied where the percentage is used.

What The Airborne Microbe Claim Needs

CSSA material reports an 80 percent airborne microbe reduction within 30 minutes.

That is commercially important because buyers in healthcare, care, education and FM often ask whether aircare evidence is only about smell, or whether it has been tested against other airborne challenges.

However, the original airborne microbe report is essential before EcoBreeze should use that figure as a public proof claim.

Procurement teams should ask:

  • which independent laboratory carried out the test
  • whether the lab was accredited for the relevant method
  • what airborne microbes, organisms or test markers were used
  • whether the test used viable organisms, particle counters, colony counts or another measurement method
  • what chamber size and airflow conditions were used
  • which EcoBreeze configuration was tested
  • whether fragrance was present
  • how long the device ran before measurement
  • what the baseline and control results were
  • how many repeats were completed
  • what uncertainty, limitations or exclusions were stated
  • whether the claim is approved for public use

Until that file is attached, the 80 percent figure should be treated as an approval-required claim.

Do not convert it into:

  • pathogen removal
  • infection prevention
  • clinical protection
  • sterilisation
  • safe air
  • healthcare compliance
  • CQC compliance
  • food-safety compliance
  • allergy or asthma protection
  • proof that cleaning is effective

The safe message is:

CSSA material reports an 80 percent airborne microbe reduction figure within 30 minutes. EcoBreeze should provide the original microbiology report and approved wording before this figure is used as a public or tender performance claim.

Why Lab Conditions Matter

Independent testing is valuable because it gives buyers a more objective starting point.

But laboratory evidence is not the same as a site guarantee.

EPA guidance frames filtration as part of a wider indoor-air approach that includes source control and ventilation. ASHRAE also cautions that filtration and air-cleaning effectiveness depends on contaminant type, airflow, installation, maintenance and context.

That matters in commercial washrooms.

A chamber test can help answer:

  • can the system reduce a defined challenge under defined conditions?
  • what configuration was tested?
  • how quickly was the effect observed?
  • how did the device compare with the control?
  • what measurement method was used?

A chamber test cannot answer every site question.

It cannot prove by itself that:

  • a blocked drain has been fixed
  • cleaning standards are adequate
  • ventilation is adequate
  • every room will perform the same way
  • every odour source will reduce at the same rate
  • user complaints will stop
  • infection risk is reduced
  • legal duties have been met

That is why EcoBreeze evidence should be used as part of a layered site decision.

The practical sequence is:

  1. Identify the odour source.
  2. Confirm cleaning, drainage and ventilation are being managed.
  3. Select the right EcoBreeze route.
  4. Place and service the device correctly.
  5. Use test evidence to support the product decision.
  6. Use Smart reporting where operational visibility is required.
  7. Review complaints, site conditions and service records over time.

How This Evidence Supports EcoBreeze Standard

EcoBreeze Standard is the route for commercial washrooms and shared spaces where controlled fragrance is suitable.

The malodour evidence supports the Standard buyer conversation because it helps move the buyer away from the idea that the product is simply adding a pleasant smell.

The buyer conversation becomes:

  • filtration comes first
  • activated carbon is part of the odour-control story
  • fragrance is optional and controlled
  • independent testing has been carried out
  • percentage claims need the original report and approved wording
  • site performance still depends on cleaning, source control, ventilation, placement and servicing

That is a more credible procurement conversation than "it smells nice."

How This Evidence Supports EcoBreeze Pure

EcoBreeze Pure is the route for spaces where added fragrance is unsuitable.

The test evidence matters for Pure because sensitive-environment buyers often need to know whether odour control can be discussed without relying on scent masking.

The evidence summary should help buyers understand that:

  • EcoBreeze is built around filtration-first aircare
  • Pure is the no-added-fragrance route
  • odour-control evidence should be separated from fragrance preference
  • controlled test evidence can support buyer due diligence
  • Pure should not be described as allergy-safe, asthma-safe or medically protective

For healthcare, care, education and food-preparation-adjacent spaces, the most useful Pure claim is not a medical claim.

It is a procurement claim:

EcoBreeze Pure gives buyers a no-added-fragrance route for filtration-first odour control where fragrance masking is unsuitable, and performance evidence can be reviewed separately from scent preference.

Tender-Safe Summary Wording

Use this wording only after the evidence file has been checked against the buyer response.

EcoBreeze has independent test evidence relating to malodour reduction under controlled conditions. Public St. Croix Sensory test documentation reports 89 percent reduction of a simulated fecal malodour after 30 minutes for the tested carbon plus fragrance configuration. CSSA material also reports an 80 percent airborne microbe reduction figure within 30 minutes, which should be supported by the original microbiology report before use as a tender or performance claim. EcoBreeze performance evidence should be read with the original test conditions and should not be treated as a substitute for cleaning, ventilation, drainage maintenance, inspection or site-specific assessment.

Concise wording: EcoBreeze can provide independent test evidence for review, including controlled malodour testing and reported airborne microbe reduction evidence. Quantified claims should be used only with the original reports, tested configuration and approved wording attached.

Procurement Evidence Checklist

Before using the 89 percent or 80 percent figures in a tender, ask for:

Evidence itemWhy procurement needs it
Original St. Croix Sensory reportConfirms the malodour test method, configuration, result and limitations
Original airborne microbe reportRequired before the 80 percent figure is used as proof
Product equivalence noteConfirms whether the tested Washroom Wizard configuration maps to current EcoBreeze Standard, Pure or Smart products
Tested configurationClarifies whether carbon only, carbon plus fragrance or another setup was used
Test conditionsShows chamber size, time points, baseline, control, humidity, airflow and other relevant factors
Lab identity and accreditation statusHelps buyers assess independence, competence and suitability of the test provider
Reviewed claim wordingPrevents overclaiming and ensures buyer, tender and website wording is consistent
Current product datasheetConfirms the current product route, features, consumables and service process
Installation and service guidanceHelps buyers understand conditions for appropriate deployment
Claims exclusionsStates what the evidence does not prove

Safe Claims, Approval-Required Claims And No-Go Claims

Safer Claims

These are the types of claims that are usually safer, subject to final EcoBreeze approval:

  • EcoBreeze has independent malodour testing evidence available for buyer review.
  • The public St. Croix Sensory report describes controlled chamber malodour testing.
  • The reported malodour result should be read with the original report and tested configuration.
  • EcoBreeze is positioned around filtration-first odour control rather than fragrance-only masking.
  • EcoBreeze Pure gives buyers a no-added-fragrance route where fragrance masking is unsuitable.
  • Lab evidence should be considered alongside cleaning, source control, ventilation, placement and servicing.

Approval-Required Claims

These need original evidence and exact approved wording:

  • 89 percent malodour reduction within 30 minutes
  • 80 percent airborne microbe reduction within 30 minutes
  • any lab-to-product equivalence statement
  • any carbon-only performance statement
  • any fragrance-free performance comparison
  • any VOC, gas or pollutant reduction statement
  • any room-size or coverage statement
  • any customer result or site performance claim

Claims To Avoid

Do not say EcoBreeze:

  • total odour elimination claims
  • whole-VOC removal claims
  • all-airborne-microbe removal claims
  • pathogen-kill claims
  • air sterilisation claims
  • infection-prevention claims
  • asthma or allergy prevention claims
  • legal or sector compliance claims for healthcare, care, school or food-prep settings
  • cleaning-substitution claims
  • ventilation-substitution claims
  • drainage-maintenance substitution claims
  • cleaning-quality proof claims
  • complaint-reduction guarantees
  • identical-result claims for every washroom

How procurement and facilities teams Should Use This Summary

Use this summary to open the evidence conversation, not to close it too quickly.

Good use:

  • attach it after a procurement call
  • use it to explain what the 89 percent and 80 percent figures mean
  • use it to show that EcoBreeze is filtration-first
  • use it to explain why original reports are needed
  • use it to support Pure discussions in fragrance-sensitive environments
  • use it to support Standard discussions where buyers are comparing air fresheners
  • use it to stop procurement and facilities teams from overclaiming

Poor use:

  • copying percentages into adverts without approval
  • using CSSA wording without the original microbe report
  • using EcoBreeze as health-outcome evidence
  • using lab data as a guarantee for every room
  • claiming that EcoBreeze fixes cleaning, drainage or ventilation problems

The right close is simple:

If you need to use the independent test figures in a tender, request the full EcoBreeze evidence file so the original reports, tested configuration and approved wording can be attached.

Buyer Questions To Ask Before Specifying

Procurement teams should ask:

  • Which EcoBreeze product route is being proposed: Standard, Pure or Smart?
  • Is added fragrance acceptable for this site?
  • Is the buyer asking for odour control, fragrance, operational evidence or all three?
  • Which independent test report is being relied on?
  • Does the report match the product route being specified?
  • Does the report test carbon only or carbon plus fragrance?
  • What does the airborne microbe report actually measure?
  • What are the limitations of the test?
  • What evidence will be supplied in the tender response?
  • What claims are approved for publication?
  • What site conditions could affect real-world performance?
  • Who will maintain the device and replace consumables?
  • Is Smart reporting needed to support service visibility?

Request The Full Evidence File

This summary gives procurement teams a clear starting point.

The next step is the full evidence file.

That file should include the original reports, current datasheets, product route confirmation, reviewed claim wording and any buyer-specific notes needed for the tender or site review.

Request the full evidence file if you need to:

  • use the 89 percent malodour figure in a proposal
  • use the 80 percent airborne microbe figure in a proposal
  • support a healthcare, care, education or FM tender
  • specify EcoBreeze Pure for a sensitive environment
  • compare EcoBreeze with fragrance-led air fresheners
  • brief procurement, health and safety or estates stakeholders

FAQ Section

What independent testing does EcoBreeze have?

EcoBreeze has public and third-party references to independent testing around malodour reduction and airborne microbe reduction. The publicly available St. Croix Sensory report supports a controlled-chamber malodour test for a tested Washroom Wizard configuration. CSSA material reports 89 percent malodour reduction and 80 percent airborne microbe reduction within 30 minutes. Original reports and approved wording should be supplied before those figures are used as public or tender claims.

Can EcoBreeze claim 89 percent malodour reduction?

Only with the correct evidence file and approved wording. The public St. Croix Sensory report reports 89 percent odour reduction after 30 minutes under defined test conditions for the tested configuration. That should not be turned into a universal claim for every washroom or every EcoBreeze setup without approval.

Can EcoBreeze claim 80 percent airborne microbe reduction?

Not from the CSSA listing alone. CSSA material reports the 80 percent figure, but the original airborne microbe report, test method, lab details, tested configuration and approved wording should be attached before EcoBreeze uses the figure as a public or tender performance claim.

Does the test evidence support infection-prevention claims?

No. Malodour and airborne microbe evidence should not be converted into infection-prevention, pathogen-removal, clinical, hygiene or health-outcome claims. EcoBreeze evidence supports aircare and buyer due diligence; it does not replace infection-control, cleaning, ventilation or healthcare governance processes.

Does independent testing prove identical site results?

No. Laboratory testing shows performance under defined test conditions. Real-world performance depends on factors such as odour source, ventilation, cleaning, humidity, room layout, placement, servicing and product configuration.

Why does the tested configuration matter?

The tested configuration tells buyers whether the result came from carbon only, carbon plus fragrance, a particular device setup, a specific filter condition or another arrangement. Without that detail, procurement teams cannot know how closely the report matches the product being specified.

How does this evidence support EcoBreeze Pure?

EcoBreeze Pure is the no-added-fragrance route. Test evidence helps buyers separate odour-control performance from fragrance preference, but Pure should not be described as allergy-safe, asthma-safe, clinically protective or suitable for every individual sensitivity.

What should procurement ask EcoBreeze for?

Procurement teams should ask for the original test reports, current product datasheets, product-equivalence note, tested configuration, reviewed claim wording, installation guidance, service guidance and any buyer-specific tender wording needed for the proposed site.

References

Talk to EcoBreeze about this authority guide

If this guide relates to a current washroom, aircare, tender or facilities challenge, EcoBreeze can help you choose the right product route and supporting evidence.

Speak to EcoBreeze